Showing posts with label churchill falls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label churchill falls. Show all posts

Sunday, June 10, 2007

Supply Chain: The Transportation of Energy

This piece was previously published earlier this year in the energy supplement of Atlantic Business Magazine.

------------------------------------------------

The curious paradox of the energy market is that supplies are seldom located very close to demand; the industry term for that is stranded. So, as an energy-rich region develops its sources, the challenge becomes what to do with the stranded energy - how to get it to customers

The practical problem for Atlantic Canada as an energy supplier is that it lies some distance from the largest energy-consuming markets.

The solution depends on which form of energy you want to sell. The obstacles are variously technical, economic and/or political.

Natural Gas

Natural gas has a well-developed transportation infrastructure in the Maritimes. The Sable Offshore Energy Project, for example, transports natural gas by underwater pipeline to a shore facility for processing and then to the US through a larger pipeline network into Maine. That’s possible because of the proximity of Sable to land, the absence of iceberg hazard to the pipes and the relatively short distance to the US.

In the Newfoundland and Labrador offshore, estimates of discovered gas range up to 9 trillion cubic feet (tcf) on the Grand Banks and the Labrador shelf, with a possible additional 36tcf or more in undiscovered conventional resources. Undiscovered unconventional resources consist of gas that is known to lie underground and has been penetrated by drilling, but lies in rock types that have not yet seen large scale commercial production.

The substantial distance from source to closest landfall and the risk of iceberg scour are impedients to a sea floor pipeline to on-shore processing facilities. Generally, the solutions proposed so far focus on sea-based transportation of either LNG (liquified natural gas) liquified at sea or CNG (compressed natural gas).

LNG is natural gas cooled at the production source to 160 Celsius to reach a liquid state. At 1/600th of its original volume, it is then shipped to a re-gasification plant closer to market. There, it is returned to gaseous form for delivery to customers, generally through pipelines but also by truck. It is the international standard for transportation and shipping of natural gas.

But LNG facilities for liquification and re-gasification are enormously expensive, and LNG has never been produced on an offshore platform.

CNG, on the other hand, is simply natural gas that is compressed to reduce volume but remains in gas form – essentially form ready for consumer use. CNG is easier to produce and easier to handle. Of course you produce it – it’s a product; the word is being used in the general sense of producing any product and not in the specialised oil and gas, sense. CNG vessels can fill up at the field, using a relatively low cost offshore mooring buoy, and then steam directly to market without needing re-gasification. This is what the literature says. . they mean low-cost compared to a $500mill+ liquification facility

There remains considerable difference in opinion regarding Atlantic Canada’s supply forecasts to 2020. These are dependent on international factors such as gas prices, stability of supply and international demand as well as domestic factors such the cooperation of local political actors. The forecasts range from no production to an optimistic possible high of 2.3 Bcf/d in 2020.

Although commercial development of Newfoundland and Labrador’s stranded gas is not anticipated before 2020, the industry has been exploring transportation options and opportunities while the provincial government is busily finalizing a natural gas royalty regime.

Several companies in particular are studying natural gas transportation and have different takes on it.

Newfoundland LNG takes a conventional approach and has announced plans to build North America's first LNG storage and transshipment facility at Grassy Point on Placentia Bay in southeastern Newfoundland. This St. John's based company is expecting a burgeoning market for LNG transshipment facilities for overseas imports entering the North American marketplace because of the economics of the LNG trade in the Atlantic Basin.

The facility would include eight 160,000 cubic metre storage tanks, three jetties with berthing facilities capable of mooring 265,000 cubic metre LNG cargo ships, and a tugboat basin along one of North America's deepest ice free ports. It will not include re-gasification facilities because of the lack of local end use markets.

The project, which is expected to accommodate up to 400 vessels per year, is slated to begin construction next summer and come into service in late 2010.

An emerging player in the international gas transport business is EnerSea Transport of Houston, Texas. They claim to have developed the first cost effective CNG marine transport and storage system. Called VOTRANS (Volume Optimized Transport and Storage), the prototype is an ocean going gas delivery system comprising large diameter pipes contained within insulated structures integrated onto specially designed and constructed ships or barges. Their Atlantic Canadian presence is the St. John’s based EnerSea Canada, a highly active player in the Newfoundland and Labrador R&D community.

A home-grown variation on CNG is a concept championed by Trans Ocean Gas, also based in St. John’s. They have designed and patented fibre-reinforced modular plastic pressure vessels that can be fitted on ships, barges or trucks. Destructive burst testing on full scale fibre reinforced plastic pressure vessels will be conducted at Atlantic Steelworks facility in Sheet Harbour NS this fall.

The company has also announced an extension to their concept taking out patents for a plastic vessel designed to transport pressurized LNG, a high density liquefied natural gas form created by combining low temperatures with relatively low pressures.

Whatever the transportation solution adopted by the market factors such as strong natural gas prices over the long term, establishment of a royalty regime, continued exploration of new basins, uncertainty of LNG imports to the U.S. from overseas and the province's relative proximity to the U.S. market, all bode well for the development of the province's natural gas reserves.

Hydro

In the long term, the region’s largest single source of new energy is the proposed Lower Churchill development in central Labrador. This recently announced $9 billion hydro-electric project would produce roughly 4000 MW of energy every year that the facility remains in working order and water continues to flow.

Unlike oil, this source of energy is virtually infinite. Its operating costs are comparatively low, although the capital costs are comparable to offshore oil or higher.

But the question of getting it to market is fraught with political and technical challenges and is realistically limited to three options: selling generated power to Quebec, wheeling it through Quebec or developing the co-called “Anglo-Saxon route”.

The political problem with selling Lower Churchill power to Québec is the infamous 1969 Upper Churchill pact between former Newfoundland premier Joey Smallwood and his Québec counterpart, Jean Jacques Bertrand. At the time, Québec refused to provide a transmission right of way to the US.

A deal was signed requiring Newfoundland to sell power to Hydro Québec at a predetermined low price while Québec was free to resell the power to American buyers for whatever price the market would bear. When the 1970s energy crisis and inflation caused prices to soar, the result was a $14 billion windfall for Quebec between 1976 and 1995, while Newfoundland made do with $2 billion in net profit according to Newfoundland government estimates. The deal expires in 2041.

That history ensures that any deal that involves selling power to Québec will be a tough political sell in Newfoundland and Labrador. Compounding this difficulty is a declaration by Premier Williams that there could be no Lower Churchill deal with Québec unless Upper Churchill was revisited. But after more than 20 years of failed interprovincial litigation aimed at just that end, Québec remains disinclined to re-open the previous deal.

The second option, wheeling the power through Québec, is being actively pursued. Two choices present themselves. The first is that Québec would agree to transmit the power along their own lines for a fee. The Newfoundland and Labrador government has submitted a request to the government of Québec for quotes on power transmission.

However, because Québec is working to develop its own hydro projects, there may be no capacity left to carry additional power from Churchill Falls. That leaves the option of Québec granting permission for Newfoundland and Labrador to construct transmission lines through the province to the US or Ontario. Last estimates put that additional capital cost at $3 billion.

Finally, there’s the much-debated “Anglo-Saxon route” or Maritime route. First explored by Smallwood in 1964 to thwart Québec’s ‘revenge of geography’, this option involves running power lines east through Labrador, under the straits to the northern tip of the island of Newfoundland, down the west coast, under the gulf straits to the Maritimes and then finally into the US - all in order to bypass Québec territory.

Smallwood’s best estimate concluded that this route would cost almost $1 billion and would raise the price of electricity so much that it could no longer be sold at a competitive rate in the US market. No doubt today’s costs would be much higher.

And so Atlantic Canada grapples with the energy paradox. Having a source, even in abundance, is only the first step to viable development. There must also be effective ways of moving energy to market, so that it is competitively priced when it get there. Fortunately, there are always people, companies and universities in Atlantic Canada ready to generate and invest in innovative solutions to do that.

Friday, June 08, 2007

Atlantic Canada Energy Superstore

This was previously published in Atlantic Business Magazine earlier this year

-----------------------------------------

In just 25 years, the image of Atlantic Canada’s energy industry has narrowed to just one source: is oil and gas. Petroleum is the first thing we think of, in part because of the success of the industry and in part because local governments have made so much of it.

But beyond petroleum are other regional sources of energy, some new and some long-standing, which have the potential to fuel Atlantic Canada’s social and economic growth well into the future.

Some provinces have developed aggressive energy policies to broaden their supply. For example, the Nova Scotia government introduced new regulations to ensure that nearly 20% of the province's electricity comes from renewable sources by 2013. Newfoundland and Labrador’s energy plan, first announced in 1998, is nearing completion after almost a decade of revisions responding to changing energy technologies, markets and prices.

The underlying reasons for provincial governments’ interest in energy are many: ever-escalating prices of conventional fuels, reports of dwindling or unstable petroleum supplies, new environmental considerations, technology advancement or just the desire to make the most out of local resources.

Wind and Wave

The popular (and very real) image of the region’s wind-swept cliffs overlooking a roiling ocean has led many an Atlantic innovator to explore the possibility of harnessing the power of wind and wave, especially for isolated communities detached from wider grids.

For wind energy, the concept is simple: erect wind-driven turbines to generate electricity and feed it into the grid. In practice, things are a little more complicated.

First, its energy can only be captured while the wind is blowing, and wind stubbornly refuses to blow in predictable, consistent ways. So, since we can’t make wind more reliable, efforts have concentrated on finding ways to store the energy from the turbines or on developing hybrid systems where wind energy is supplemented as needed by a more dependable source such as diesel.

The other issue is the economic one - turbines are expensive. Great strides have been made in bringing down the costs of wind energy: over the past decade the cost per kilowatt hour has dropped from 10 cents to about 7 cents. However, it still compares poorly to energy at 4 cents a kilowatt produced from coal.

On Ramea Island off the south coast of Newfoundland, Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro is developing a $9.7 million wind hydrogen pilot project using 6 turbines. The goal is to use wind power to produce (through electrolysis) hydrogen that can be stored in tanks for later use. This demonstration project is meant to be up and running by Fall 2008, and Hydro will spend the next three years working out the bugs for development of a final, commercial plant.

PEI, however, is the regional leader, as the home of the Atlantic Wind Test Site (AWTS). Established in 1980 as Canada’s National Wind Energy Laboratory, AWTS is the cornerstone of Canada’s wind energy R&D program. A wind farm located on the northern tip of PEI now produces 5% or about 11 megawatts of the power used by the province's 139,000 residents, and the PEI government has announced an ambitious plan to produce 100% of the island's electricity with wind energy by 2015.

In the case of tidal power, the first thought falls on New Brunswick and the famed Bay of Fundy. And for good reason - in some places the water rises and falls some 16 metres over a 24 hour period. That means, twice a day, there is a reliable source of potential energy that will continue for as long as we have a moon to gaze at.

There are two ways to harness tidal power. The traditional method uses a barrage system to capture the water at high tide and release it through turbines at low tide. Nova Scotia Power already operates a tidal generating station in Annapolis Royal. This plant, which happens to be the second largest tidal generating facility in the world, produces about 20MW of power annually.

More recent technology uses generators mounted on poles anchored to the sea floor, where passing currents turn underwater “windmills”. Because water is 800 times denser than air, the turbine blades can be smaller than those needed to generate the same amount of electricity from wind.

The government of New Brunswick has been studying this technology and says it will continue to explore the idea and encourage the construction of demonstration projects. Studies suggests that two sites in Nova Scotia's Minas Basin, at the extreme eastern end of the Bay of Fundy, are the most suitable in all of North America for this technology. Those two sites alone could conceivably generate 333 MW of power.

Hydroelectricity

Hydro is widely considered the cleanest, most reliable, most cost-effective of the major energy sources. While the Maritimes derive most of its energy from other sources, Newfoundland and Labrador is heavily hydro-dependent, with the potential for even more generation capacity in Labrador.

The now infamous Churchill Falls hydroelectric generating facility in Labrador produces a staggering 5,428.5MW, some 225MW is diverted to feeding the industrial needs of Wabush Mines in Labrador, but the rest is destined for Northeastern US markets by way of neighbouring Quebec. Further down the mighty Churchill River lies the potential for another great hydro project: Premier Danny Williams recently announced a call for Expressions of Interest to develop the Lower Churchill. Although still in the conceptual stage, this project could include a 2100MW dam at Gull Island, an 824MW dam at Muskrat Falls and 1000MW upgrade to the existing facility at the Churchill Falls power plant, thus increasing the current energy output by an extra 4000 MW to a total of over 9000 MW for the entire Churchill River hydroelectric complex.

Nuclear

Atlantic Canada is not generally seen as a centre for nuclear energy, but the region has a nuclear past and a nuclear future.

The region’s only nuclear power station lies at Point Lepreau in New Brunswick. This CANDU heavy water reactor was constructed between 1975 and 1983. With a total output of 640 MW, it supplies roughly one third of the province’s energy needs.

Originally designed to last 25 years, Point Lepreau was scheduled to be mothballed by 2008. In July 2005 NB Power awarded Atomic Energy of Canada a $1.4 billion contract for refurbishing the facility. This will extend the reactor's lifespan by approximately 25 years.

Meantime, Newfoundland and Labrador is now a hotbed of uranium exploration, with approximately 25 companies expressing interest. Labrador has significant uranium deposits and was extensively explored in the 60s and 70s. With the uranium price collapsed of the 80s (due to the end of the cold war and the growing unpopularity of nuclear energy), prospecting efforts waned and the world saw a widespread shutdown of nuclear operations.

But recently, uranium prices have hit new highs and the market is set to keep accelerating. According to a report by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), 130 new nuclear power plants may be built in the next 15 years – and uranium is the main element needed to fuel them.

Coal

Higher energy prices across the board mean that recently uneconomic sources become economic once again. And coal, a veteran fuel with a bad environmental reputation, is responding to technological advances that make it possible to burn more cleanly than ever before.

So in coal-rich jurisdictions like Cape Breton, companies are looking at the geology to determine if the coal missed in the previous developments are worth re-accessing today.

It turns out that some are.

Swiss mining giant Xstrata Coal won a bid to resurrect an undeveloped coal mine in Cape Breton, more than a decade after it was abandoned and years after miners on the island had given up hope on the industry. Company sources have indicated up to 300 jobs might be created in a region with one of the highest unemployment rates in the country.

This interest is separate and distinct from next-level energy projects seeking to determine the viability and economics of previously untapped coalbed methane. The next wave for coal may not be conventional mining made viable by higher prices and cleaner technology, but entirely new projects made possible by the unrelenting search for new uses for “underutilized” associated fuels.

Conclusion

As long as people need energy, the world will find ways to extract and supply it. These are just some of the existing and future energy sources that make Atlantic Canada such an energy big box store - a wide variety of selection and lots of each kind of item.