Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Jobs Out East

This piece was previously published earlier this year in the energy supplement of Atlantic Business Magazine.

------------------------------------------------

Newfoundland and Labrador’s talk radio shows are abuzz with the latest personal stories of out-migration. The media is reporting the recent addition of a direct flight from rural Newfoundland to northern Alberta, to better serve those workers on a 6-week-on 2-week-off work rotation to the land of opportunity.

Out-migration and migrant work practices are even on Premier Williams’ mind: on a recent trade mission to Alberta, he took the time to reassure the members of the Newfoundland and Labrador diaspora in Fort MacMurray that they would be able to come home in a decade.

There is another side to this story.

While one end of the petroleum labour force is packing its bags and heading out to work the western oilfields, up the ladder at the knowledge end of the industry there’s not necessarily a rush to the airport. In fact, some people are happy where they are.

Take the example of Production Services Network (PSN).

PSN was formerly the production services arm of Kellogg Brown and Root’s (KBR) energy and chemicals division, a subsidiary of the Haliburton Group, prior to a management buyout. These days PSN is a major independent international service contractor to oil and gas exploration and production customers around the world.

While they maintain field offices in 25 countries around the globe to gather initial information, that data is then transmitted to just three engineering centres: Sidney, Aberdeen and St. John’s.

According to Roger Clarke, PSN’s General Manager and Vice President of Canada Operations, the centre in St. John’s was originally established to provide engineering and related professional services to the Hibernia project. They have been here ever since. And because of changes in technology, there is simply no reason to move and there’s every reason to stay. Last year the St. John’s operation expanded to 280 employees.

“With the way technology is running these days, we can engineer remotely. We can produce deliverables here and electronically ship them to wherever we have to. The customer can review the work, comment on it and return it back to us. Ten years ago you couldn’t do it,” says Clark.

With the ability to send large quantities of data quickly, cheaply and securely, engineering offices can be located anywhere, even at great distance. “Whether it’s an upgrader in Fort MacMurray or a mechanical plant in the UK, we can engineer far away from the customer sites.”

The local office provides engineering services to two local projects, Terra Nova and Hibernia, as well as for a client in Bakersfield, California and a North Sea project.

But if technology allows for remote engineering from a distant location, why not just do it all from the head office in Aberdeen? “Because Aberdeen has the same problem as Calgary: the resources available are simply maxed out - office space, engineering staff.”

Besides the technical side, there is a shift in customer attitudes. Clark says that previously, customers would insist that engineering work be done close to the site. Ironically, that’s how PSN ended up in St. John’s in the first place. Today, that’s not an automatic requirement.

Roger Clark is a strong advocate for the PSN business model of a local office doing global engineering and thereby creating a local demand for professional knowledge workers.

Jerry Byrne, President of offshore engineering and fabrication company D. F. Barnes and Chair of petroleum sector trade association NOIA, is also an advocate of retaining local expertise - which in his case includes skilled trades as well as engineers - while serving national and global markets. His firm is pursuing opportunities where components can be fabricated in Newfoundland and Labrador and then exported to other parts of the world.

His philosophy is simple: “import the contracts and export the products”. This is possible because the distance from Atlantic Canada to the Alberta oilsands is 53 feet, the length of a flatbed truck. Anything that can fit on one of those, or in a standard shipping container, can be built here with local skilled labour and then be transported anywhere in the world.

Recently, the D.F. Barnes Group of Companies was awarded a multi-million dollar manufacturing contract with Oceaneering International, Inc., the world’s largest supplier of remotely operated vehicles (ROVs) for use by the oil and gas industry. D.F. Barnes will manufacture launch and recovery systems, called LARS. These are large mechanical devices used to put the ROVs over side during offshore operations and then take them back aboard when their work is done.

This contract establishes the D.F. Barnes Group as one of three worldwide suppliers of LARS, serving Oceaneering’s North America and Western Europe marketplace.

Improved transportation infrastructure combined with exploding demand and the inability of established manufacturing centres to deliver within a reasonable time frame opens the window to this kind of award. As a bonus, it also allows skilled tradesmen to stay in the province and even encourages some to come back. This is not only good for the skilled workforce, but a competitive advantage for companies seeking to attract engineering and fabrication contracts.

The cases of PSN and D.F. Barnes show how Atlantic Canada can take advantage of the global trend towards outsourcing. Instead of trying to keep high-cost personnel in a high-cost location where you have to compete with other companies for professional staff, it’s possible to establish an office at any lower-cost location anywhere and service your customer base from there.

This business model emphasises continuity and making best use of accumulated experience by creating stability for the team. It avoid the costs of uprooting to follow projects around the world. The oil and gas sector is a mobile one, where staff follow projects around the world because new projects are always being developed while other projects move out of the development phase and into the production phase.

Reestablishing the expertise of a cohesive engineering team with every move from place to place, besides the costs of rebuilding due to attrition, degrades the ability to accumulate knowledge and expertise.

St. John’s has the competitive advantage of a critical mass of related educational facilities, Memorial University engineering school and the Marine Institute in particular, an established cluster of petroleum activity and a population inclined to stay put if the opportunity presents itself.

Besides those hard business factors are the quality of life issues. St. John’s is a good place to live and raise a family in, as far as employees are concerned. If you walk into any gathering of petroleum industry professionals, you will hear a variety of accents from across Canada and around the world. Many of these people have settled into St. John’s for good - they have homes and children in school and are reluctant to uproot.

There will always be a need for people to move away from home and stay near development sites. Sometimes there is just no substitute for being close by and for gaining valuable experience under a variety of conditions that only working outside one’s home jurisdiction provides.

But PSN and D.F. Barnes show the way to an alternative business and employment model - one which can keep more knowledge and skilled workers, and therefore expertise, closer to home, while still being a player in the industry around the world.

Sunday, June 10, 2007

Belated thank you

To Judge J. Derek Green for an outstanding job well done.

Including remedial legislation in the report was above and beyond the call of duty. Little wonder it took so much time to complete.

While some of it might be a dry read, overall it is a riveting insight into the operations of our political class and their attitude towards the expenditure of public money for political gain.

It lifts the veil on longstanding pathetic conduct.

If implemented fully, this report should drag NL provincial politics kicking and screaming from the 19th century and set the standard for ethical political behavior in the province.

And it is about time.

Supply Chain: The Transportation of Energy

This piece was previously published earlier this year in the energy supplement of Atlantic Business Magazine.

------------------------------------------------

The curious paradox of the energy market is that supplies are seldom located very close to demand; the industry term for that is stranded. So, as an energy-rich region develops its sources, the challenge becomes what to do with the stranded energy - how to get it to customers

The practical problem for Atlantic Canada as an energy supplier is that it lies some distance from the largest energy-consuming markets.

The solution depends on which form of energy you want to sell. The obstacles are variously technical, economic and/or political.

Natural Gas

Natural gas has a well-developed transportation infrastructure in the Maritimes. The Sable Offshore Energy Project, for example, transports natural gas by underwater pipeline to a shore facility for processing and then to the US through a larger pipeline network into Maine. That’s possible because of the proximity of Sable to land, the absence of iceberg hazard to the pipes and the relatively short distance to the US.

In the Newfoundland and Labrador offshore, estimates of discovered gas range up to 9 trillion cubic feet (tcf) on the Grand Banks and the Labrador shelf, with a possible additional 36tcf or more in undiscovered conventional resources. Undiscovered unconventional resources consist of gas that is known to lie underground and has been penetrated by drilling, but lies in rock types that have not yet seen large scale commercial production.

The substantial distance from source to closest landfall and the risk of iceberg scour are impedients to a sea floor pipeline to on-shore processing facilities. Generally, the solutions proposed so far focus on sea-based transportation of either LNG (liquified natural gas) liquified at sea or CNG (compressed natural gas).

LNG is natural gas cooled at the production source to 160 Celsius to reach a liquid state. At 1/600th of its original volume, it is then shipped to a re-gasification plant closer to market. There, it is returned to gaseous form for delivery to customers, generally through pipelines but also by truck. It is the international standard for transportation and shipping of natural gas.

But LNG facilities for liquification and re-gasification are enormously expensive, and LNG has never been produced on an offshore platform.

CNG, on the other hand, is simply natural gas that is compressed to reduce volume but remains in gas form – essentially form ready for consumer use. CNG is easier to produce and easier to handle. Of course you produce it – it’s a product; the word is being used in the general sense of producing any product and not in the specialised oil and gas, sense. CNG vessels can fill up at the field, using a relatively low cost offshore mooring buoy, and then steam directly to market without needing re-gasification. This is what the literature says. . they mean low-cost compared to a $500mill+ liquification facility

There remains considerable difference in opinion regarding Atlantic Canada’s supply forecasts to 2020. These are dependent on international factors such as gas prices, stability of supply and international demand as well as domestic factors such the cooperation of local political actors. The forecasts range from no production to an optimistic possible high of 2.3 Bcf/d in 2020.

Although commercial development of Newfoundland and Labrador’s stranded gas is not anticipated before 2020, the industry has been exploring transportation options and opportunities while the provincial government is busily finalizing a natural gas royalty regime.

Several companies in particular are studying natural gas transportation and have different takes on it.

Newfoundland LNG takes a conventional approach and has announced plans to build North America's first LNG storage and transshipment facility at Grassy Point on Placentia Bay in southeastern Newfoundland. This St. John's based company is expecting a burgeoning market for LNG transshipment facilities for overseas imports entering the North American marketplace because of the economics of the LNG trade in the Atlantic Basin.

The facility would include eight 160,000 cubic metre storage tanks, three jetties with berthing facilities capable of mooring 265,000 cubic metre LNG cargo ships, and a tugboat basin along one of North America's deepest ice free ports. It will not include re-gasification facilities because of the lack of local end use markets.

The project, which is expected to accommodate up to 400 vessels per year, is slated to begin construction next summer and come into service in late 2010.

An emerging player in the international gas transport business is EnerSea Transport of Houston, Texas. They claim to have developed the first cost effective CNG marine transport and storage system. Called VOTRANS (Volume Optimized Transport and Storage), the prototype is an ocean going gas delivery system comprising large diameter pipes contained within insulated structures integrated onto specially designed and constructed ships or barges. Their Atlantic Canadian presence is the St. John’s based EnerSea Canada, a highly active player in the Newfoundland and Labrador R&D community.

A home-grown variation on CNG is a concept championed by Trans Ocean Gas, also based in St. John’s. They have designed and patented fibre-reinforced modular plastic pressure vessels that can be fitted on ships, barges or trucks. Destructive burst testing on full scale fibre reinforced plastic pressure vessels will be conducted at Atlantic Steelworks facility in Sheet Harbour NS this fall.

The company has also announced an extension to their concept taking out patents for a plastic vessel designed to transport pressurized LNG, a high density liquefied natural gas form created by combining low temperatures with relatively low pressures.

Whatever the transportation solution adopted by the market factors such as strong natural gas prices over the long term, establishment of a royalty regime, continued exploration of new basins, uncertainty of LNG imports to the U.S. from overseas and the province's relative proximity to the U.S. market, all bode well for the development of the province's natural gas reserves.

Hydro

In the long term, the region’s largest single source of new energy is the proposed Lower Churchill development in central Labrador. This recently announced $9 billion hydro-electric project would produce roughly 4000 MW of energy every year that the facility remains in working order and water continues to flow.

Unlike oil, this source of energy is virtually infinite. Its operating costs are comparatively low, although the capital costs are comparable to offshore oil or higher.

But the question of getting it to market is fraught with political and technical challenges and is realistically limited to three options: selling generated power to Quebec, wheeling it through Quebec or developing the co-called “Anglo-Saxon route”.

The political problem with selling Lower Churchill power to Québec is the infamous 1969 Upper Churchill pact between former Newfoundland premier Joey Smallwood and his Québec counterpart, Jean Jacques Bertrand. At the time, Québec refused to provide a transmission right of way to the US.

A deal was signed requiring Newfoundland to sell power to Hydro Québec at a predetermined low price while Québec was free to resell the power to American buyers for whatever price the market would bear. When the 1970s energy crisis and inflation caused prices to soar, the result was a $14 billion windfall for Quebec between 1976 and 1995, while Newfoundland made do with $2 billion in net profit according to Newfoundland government estimates. The deal expires in 2041.

That history ensures that any deal that involves selling power to Québec will be a tough political sell in Newfoundland and Labrador. Compounding this difficulty is a declaration by Premier Williams that there could be no Lower Churchill deal with Québec unless Upper Churchill was revisited. But after more than 20 years of failed interprovincial litigation aimed at just that end, Québec remains disinclined to re-open the previous deal.

The second option, wheeling the power through Québec, is being actively pursued. Two choices present themselves. The first is that Québec would agree to transmit the power along their own lines for a fee. The Newfoundland and Labrador government has submitted a request to the government of Québec for quotes on power transmission.

However, because Québec is working to develop its own hydro projects, there may be no capacity left to carry additional power from Churchill Falls. That leaves the option of Québec granting permission for Newfoundland and Labrador to construct transmission lines through the province to the US or Ontario. Last estimates put that additional capital cost at $3 billion.

Finally, there’s the much-debated “Anglo-Saxon route” or Maritime route. First explored by Smallwood in 1964 to thwart Québec’s ‘revenge of geography’, this option involves running power lines east through Labrador, under the straits to the northern tip of the island of Newfoundland, down the west coast, under the gulf straits to the Maritimes and then finally into the US - all in order to bypass Québec territory.

Smallwood’s best estimate concluded that this route would cost almost $1 billion and would raise the price of electricity so much that it could no longer be sold at a competitive rate in the US market. No doubt today’s costs would be much higher.

And so Atlantic Canada grapples with the energy paradox. Having a source, even in abundance, is only the first step to viable development. There must also be effective ways of moving energy to market, so that it is competitively priced when it get there. Fortunately, there are always people, companies and universities in Atlantic Canada ready to generate and invest in innovative solutions to do that.

Clubby the seal

Speaks for itself. Click to play.

Saturday, June 09, 2007

Criticism from away . . . Or calling it like it is

VOCM has already framed this story through their headline National Paper Aims at Premier and their lede that a mainland paper has "taken another swipe at Danny Williams." But numbers like employment rate are hard, cold and indisputable although their interpretation might be called into question.

Still, not all numbers are politics; some are just numbers whether you like them or not.

Judge for yourself.

And if you want to see the raw numbers on which this article is based, check StatsCan here and scroll down to the tables.

---------------------------------------------------------------
Danny Chavez makes life harder on the Rock

Derek DeCloet
Globe and Mail, June 9, 2007

Nothing can stop Canada's sizzling job market, and it's not just an Alberta story any more. In every province but two, unemployment is lower today than in 2000, and in absolute terms, no province has enjoyed a bigger decline in the jobless rate than Newfoundland and Labrador.

Yes, this week's employment data prove it: As Premier of the Rock, Danny Williams is an economic disaster. No, really. He is. The drop in Newfoundland's unemployment rate to 12.9 per cent sounds good - it was nearly 17 per cent at the start of the decade - but the statistic hides as much as it tells. It flatters Mr. Williams.

A more meaningful figure is the employment rate, which tells you what percentage of the labour pool is actually working (as opposed to the number who are looking for work but can't find it). The hard facts are these: barely half - 51.5 per cent - of working-age Newfoundlanders have a job, trailing everywhere else by a country mile. Forget Alberta. If only Newfoundland had the same employment rate as tiny Prince Edward Island (61 per cent), it would have 40,000 more inhabitants drawing a paycheque.

How can this be, in a province blessed with abundant oil reserves, during the greatest energy boom in a generation? I doubt that Newfoundlanders are that much lazier than other Canadians. It's about opportunity, or lack of it. Newfoundland's jobs boom is a mirage: Roughly the same number of jobs exist there today as in October, 2003, when Mr. Williams was elected. It's the size of the labour force that has shrunk, because residents are moving to Fort McMurray and other points west.

"If [companies] want to deal with South American dictators, they can go to South America," says Charles Cirtwill, acting president of the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies in Halifax. He's referring, of course, to Mr. Williams' latest gambit - to demand a 5-per-cent stake in all future oil and gas projects, at no cost to the province. A similar demand has put the brakes on Hebron, a massive offshore oil development led by Exxon Mobil and Chevron.

If that smells vaguely like expropriation, or perhaps extortion, we assure you that it's merely Mr. Williams trying to get a "fair share," to use the phrase that often accompanies Newfoundlanders' grievances. Fairness is in the eye of the beholder, though. Wade Locke, an economist at Memorial University, found that government's take of offshore oil projects is 51 to 55 per cent of pretax cash flow - "similar to the shares found in Alaska, Alberta and Australia." The province gets a larger piece than Ottawa.

So lush are the royalties from energy that they could turn Newfoundland into a "have" province by about 2012, ending decades of equalization payments from the feds, Mr. Locke writes. Inconveniently, that would also bring an end to Mr. Williams' popular stunts to protest that multibillion-dollar gifts of equalization are not enough. Politically, that's magic. Mr. Williams' Conservatives enjoy more than 70 per cent approval in recent polls.

But if extreme confrontation works for squeezing more dough out of Ottawa, it doesn't work for business. When it comes to the Premier's tiresome Danny Chavez routine, oil companies don't know where the demands will stop. In Hebron, the government first demanded a 4.9-per-cent stake. Mr. Williams' Natural Resources Minister is already warning that it will ask for more, once negotiations resume. "If you're an investor, you're not interested in finding a resource that may be nationalized four or five years from now," says Mr. Cirtwill of AIMS.

Don't laugh. That's essentially what happened to Fishery Products International. The province didn't reclaim ownership of FPI, but successive Liberal and Tory governments neutered the company. Twice since 2001, the province amended the FPI Act, obstructing a merger attempt and meddling in restructuring plans. John Risley, who was part of the investor group that took control of the company in 2001, remembers getting a phone call from FPI's lead banker. "He said, 'You guys don't run this business any more. The government does.' "

FPI is being sold now in pieces - only after the province imposed conditions that will force the buyers to prop up rural towns in Newfoundland. Mr. Risley says breaking up the company was the only way to get it out from under the government's thumb. The quickest way to fix the poisoned business environment would be for voters to kick Mr. Williams out this fall, but Mr. Cirtwill just laughs at the idea. "The only real question is, is he going to win every seat?"

Friday, June 08, 2007

Editorialist, heal thyself

Today's column from Brian Jones is a peculiar one. For the first 7/8's or so, he excoriates the Liberal opposition, lambasting them not reforming their give-away mentality, most notably demonstrated through Voisey's Bay.

Oddly, he can't seem to provide any real evidence for that "giveaway" other than repeating the same old hoary Williams government unexamined claim that it is one.

He also conveniently ignores that all the millions upon millions of dollars flowing into the provincial treasury every year, the same millions which allow this government the financial cushion to turn their back on new projects, were negotiated under Liberal governments.

Are the Liberal taking the political hit in this new "No Giveaways" public environment? They certainly are. But the problem with this "No Giveaways" public environment is that it is unsustainable for the province.

First, the position is predicated on a negative. What government claims as their guiding principle is the equivalent of "We won't do stupid things." And that's great, as fine as it goes. Not doing stupid things is a fine and laudable goal. No government wants to do stupid things and no government comes into office planning to do stupid things (with rare exceptions like the Khmer Rouge or the Ontario NDP).

Second, there is only one way to not do stupid things and that's to do nothing at all. As long as official government policy is to fight fight fight no matter what, then there really is no chance of committing to anything stupid.

There is also no chance of committing to anything smart.

Third, as long as government is rewarded for the fight fight fight and enough people of the province feel no cost to that fight, then government will keep it up.

Finally, fighting is easy because it involves making no choices. While fighting makes you popular, making deals means give and take and choosing among what's the most important. Hibernia made the choice of balancing infrastructure development (Bull Arm) and jobs (gravity base) and put off royalties; Terra Nova chose higher and more immediate royalties and lower local job activity.

Voisey's Bay also entailed a delicate balance of choices.

It's too easy to assail Hibernia for low royalties while ignoring the development of world-class infrastructure and the thousands of jobs it created just as it's too easy to lambaste Terra Nova for the engineering jobs that never came while ignoring the steady flow of funds into the provincial treasury.

It's easy and it's cheap. And it happens all the time from people who should know better.

Fighting for everything at once means never having to choose. And making choices and balancing off rewards means spending political capital; and this government is a miserly one.

Mr. Jones ends his editorial with these lines:
The premier has achieved almost rock-star status, even though he's only half right in the ongoing Battle of the Atlantic Accord. Like too many others, the Liberals opted to become Williams' cheerleaders on that issue, instead of challenging him to produce some hard facts and numbers to support his case. They seem to be afraid to challenge the accord hysteria and Dannymania that has gripped the province.

Out of touch, and gutless to boot - it doesn't sound like a winning platform.
Of course Mr. Jones has already acted as a Williams cheerleader in virtually every paragraph in his piece up to that point. At no point does he ask any hard questions preferring instead to swallow the government bait whole.

And then he criticizes the opposition for doing the same and for refraining from issuing the challenge that Mr. Jones himself cannot issue?

The point missed is that as long as the public environment leans towards taking government at it's word without critical analysis and generating and reinforcing myths and revisionist history thereby creating an attitude which encourages a socially enforced consensus (speaking with one voice), opposition comes at a cost.

It's a political cost and it's a personal cost. After a while, even the strongest get fed up with speaking out with only bricks to the head for acknowledgement.

That doesn't mean that there should be no legitimate opposition and responsible alternative point of view. It just means that the province is not ready to listen to one yet.

Atlantic Canada Energy Superstore

This was previously published in Atlantic Business Magazine earlier this year

-----------------------------------------

In just 25 years, the image of Atlantic Canada’s energy industry has narrowed to just one source: is oil and gas. Petroleum is the first thing we think of, in part because of the success of the industry and in part because local governments have made so much of it.

But beyond petroleum are other regional sources of energy, some new and some long-standing, which have the potential to fuel Atlantic Canada’s social and economic growth well into the future.

Some provinces have developed aggressive energy policies to broaden their supply. For example, the Nova Scotia government introduced new regulations to ensure that nearly 20% of the province's electricity comes from renewable sources by 2013. Newfoundland and Labrador’s energy plan, first announced in 1998, is nearing completion after almost a decade of revisions responding to changing energy technologies, markets and prices.

The underlying reasons for provincial governments’ interest in energy are many: ever-escalating prices of conventional fuels, reports of dwindling or unstable petroleum supplies, new environmental considerations, technology advancement or just the desire to make the most out of local resources.

Wind and Wave

The popular (and very real) image of the region’s wind-swept cliffs overlooking a roiling ocean has led many an Atlantic innovator to explore the possibility of harnessing the power of wind and wave, especially for isolated communities detached from wider grids.

For wind energy, the concept is simple: erect wind-driven turbines to generate electricity and feed it into the grid. In practice, things are a little more complicated.

First, its energy can only be captured while the wind is blowing, and wind stubbornly refuses to blow in predictable, consistent ways. So, since we can’t make wind more reliable, efforts have concentrated on finding ways to store the energy from the turbines or on developing hybrid systems where wind energy is supplemented as needed by a more dependable source such as diesel.

The other issue is the economic one - turbines are expensive. Great strides have been made in bringing down the costs of wind energy: over the past decade the cost per kilowatt hour has dropped from 10 cents to about 7 cents. However, it still compares poorly to energy at 4 cents a kilowatt produced from coal.

On Ramea Island off the south coast of Newfoundland, Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro is developing a $9.7 million wind hydrogen pilot project using 6 turbines. The goal is to use wind power to produce (through electrolysis) hydrogen that can be stored in tanks for later use. This demonstration project is meant to be up and running by Fall 2008, and Hydro will spend the next three years working out the bugs for development of a final, commercial plant.

PEI, however, is the regional leader, as the home of the Atlantic Wind Test Site (AWTS). Established in 1980 as Canada’s National Wind Energy Laboratory, AWTS is the cornerstone of Canada’s wind energy R&D program. A wind farm located on the northern tip of PEI now produces 5% or about 11 megawatts of the power used by the province's 139,000 residents, and the PEI government has announced an ambitious plan to produce 100% of the island's electricity with wind energy by 2015.

In the case of tidal power, the first thought falls on New Brunswick and the famed Bay of Fundy. And for good reason - in some places the water rises and falls some 16 metres over a 24 hour period. That means, twice a day, there is a reliable source of potential energy that will continue for as long as we have a moon to gaze at.

There are two ways to harness tidal power. The traditional method uses a barrage system to capture the water at high tide and release it through turbines at low tide. Nova Scotia Power already operates a tidal generating station in Annapolis Royal. This plant, which happens to be the second largest tidal generating facility in the world, produces about 20MW of power annually.

More recent technology uses generators mounted on poles anchored to the sea floor, where passing currents turn underwater “windmills”. Because water is 800 times denser than air, the turbine blades can be smaller than those needed to generate the same amount of electricity from wind.

The government of New Brunswick has been studying this technology and says it will continue to explore the idea and encourage the construction of demonstration projects. Studies suggests that two sites in Nova Scotia's Minas Basin, at the extreme eastern end of the Bay of Fundy, are the most suitable in all of North America for this technology. Those two sites alone could conceivably generate 333 MW of power.

Hydroelectricity

Hydro is widely considered the cleanest, most reliable, most cost-effective of the major energy sources. While the Maritimes derive most of its energy from other sources, Newfoundland and Labrador is heavily hydro-dependent, with the potential for even more generation capacity in Labrador.

The now infamous Churchill Falls hydroelectric generating facility in Labrador produces a staggering 5,428.5MW, some 225MW is diverted to feeding the industrial needs of Wabush Mines in Labrador, but the rest is destined for Northeastern US markets by way of neighbouring Quebec. Further down the mighty Churchill River lies the potential for another great hydro project: Premier Danny Williams recently announced a call for Expressions of Interest to develop the Lower Churchill. Although still in the conceptual stage, this project could include a 2100MW dam at Gull Island, an 824MW dam at Muskrat Falls and 1000MW upgrade to the existing facility at the Churchill Falls power plant, thus increasing the current energy output by an extra 4000 MW to a total of over 9000 MW for the entire Churchill River hydroelectric complex.

Nuclear

Atlantic Canada is not generally seen as a centre for nuclear energy, but the region has a nuclear past and a nuclear future.

The region’s only nuclear power station lies at Point Lepreau in New Brunswick. This CANDU heavy water reactor was constructed between 1975 and 1983. With a total output of 640 MW, it supplies roughly one third of the province’s energy needs.

Originally designed to last 25 years, Point Lepreau was scheduled to be mothballed by 2008. In July 2005 NB Power awarded Atomic Energy of Canada a $1.4 billion contract for refurbishing the facility. This will extend the reactor's lifespan by approximately 25 years.

Meantime, Newfoundland and Labrador is now a hotbed of uranium exploration, with approximately 25 companies expressing interest. Labrador has significant uranium deposits and was extensively explored in the 60s and 70s. With the uranium price collapsed of the 80s (due to the end of the cold war and the growing unpopularity of nuclear energy), prospecting efforts waned and the world saw a widespread shutdown of nuclear operations.

But recently, uranium prices have hit new highs and the market is set to keep accelerating. According to a report by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), 130 new nuclear power plants may be built in the next 15 years – and uranium is the main element needed to fuel them.

Coal

Higher energy prices across the board mean that recently uneconomic sources become economic once again. And coal, a veteran fuel with a bad environmental reputation, is responding to technological advances that make it possible to burn more cleanly than ever before.

So in coal-rich jurisdictions like Cape Breton, companies are looking at the geology to determine if the coal missed in the previous developments are worth re-accessing today.

It turns out that some are.

Swiss mining giant Xstrata Coal won a bid to resurrect an undeveloped coal mine in Cape Breton, more than a decade after it was abandoned and years after miners on the island had given up hope on the industry. Company sources have indicated up to 300 jobs might be created in a region with one of the highest unemployment rates in the country.

This interest is separate and distinct from next-level energy projects seeking to determine the viability and economics of previously untapped coalbed methane. The next wave for coal may not be conventional mining made viable by higher prices and cleaner technology, but entirely new projects made possible by the unrelenting search for new uses for “underutilized” associated fuels.

Conclusion

As long as people need energy, the world will find ways to extract and supply it. These are just some of the existing and future energy sources that make Atlantic Canada such an energy big box store - a wide variety of selection and lots of each kind of item.

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

The Ellsworth amateur hour

St. John's City Councilor Ron Ellsworth has made quite a name for himself already. He has carefully and methodically carved out a reputation as a straight-talking, sensible, responsible stand-up member of a council not really known for that kind of personality.

And he's only been an active politician for less than 24 months. And it shows.

On the one hand he's done yeoman's service on city budget matters (although he folded like a deck of cards on the Mile 1 subsidy issue) and he's been pretty solid in standing up to Andy (mayor for life and Bully-in-chief) Wells.

But his inexperience shows in the political boners he's committed. One that springs to mind was his flip-flop on the retroactive, over-generous council pay increases that almost slipped through. Not only did he make the wrong call on supporting this outrage in the first place, he backslid by proposing paycuts for all members of council. This not only showed he was weak in intent at the start but that he had no problem digging himself out of his hole through transparent pandering.*

He didn't really acquit himself too well on the issue of garbage net covers either, flopping around all over the place calling for new votes every second meeting depending on which way the wind blew.

But overall he has been able to maintain credibility with the people of St. John's and the media who report on Council activities. But all that is now in jeopardy.

If there is one piece of advice I would tell any aspiring politician it would be a simple commandment: Thy Shalt Not Lie. Not complicated; just never lie. Don't lie to constituents.Don't lie in meetings.

And never never never lie to the media. That way you won't end up with the media scratching their heads and wondering about your level of credibility of anything you say in the future.

------------------------------------------------

There seems to be lots of the "politicians should take paycuts or no pay at all" going around. In the case of Premier Williams, it's held up as a sign of virtue.

Not that long ago in this province, all politicians were miserably paid, if at all. The result was that the only people who could afford to run were the independently wealthy, pensioners or those who would continue to conduct business while occupying public office.

There is no virtue in that.

Friday, June 01, 2007

Premier Williams tackles the big questions

It's not often these day that Premier Williams calls talk radio so when he does, you can count on something interesting, if not significant.

Today, his contribution to the public conversation of democracy was neither interesting nor significant.

Look at the context: the province is up in arms over a second radiologist suspension, Hydro has a brand new structure through a new government-owned holding company, the budget has just passed and there's a judicial inquiry in the wings looking at how our health system kept vital health information to itself instead of notifying patients.

All or some of these things, one would think, would be worthy of comment from the highest politician and most senior public sector executive in the land. After all, these are all items of vital public interest.

But you would be wrong.

Instead, he took his time on the public airwaves whinging and moaning about a topic important to him about which nobody outside the House cares a whit: Irish limousines.

And the host, standing in for the interests of the people of the province and in his role in promoting debate on the vital issues facing this province, let him do so without challenge.

The lesson of the day is why talk about the hard stuff when you can distract with the easy stuff. Never forget: Talk radio is entertainment.

Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Kudos to the Tely

Among my friends and family and colleagues, I'm known as a hard-core skeptic. That doesn't mean naysayer or contrarian, it means looking behind the surface of what is said to get to what is meant. It means evaluating and examining what's before you with a keen and critical eye to determine the true substance of the matter.

My background is a little strange compared to some. A formative experience was my time at a small liberal school in the US, Rhode Island College. I was recruited there by their debate coach who spotted me at a out-of-the-way tournament in Cape Breton, of all places. For two years, I spent every second weekend in debate competition against the best schools in the US - Harvard, Princeton, Yale and the other usual suspects.

Each competition meant defending or attacking topics that were thrown out with lightning speed. You learned to listen closely, evaluate what you heard, and judge the logical structures, content holes and general weaknesses in the other side's position. At the same time, you learned to formulate a persuasive position of your own that was logically solid and consistent and which would win the judges to your side.

All this was done on your feet after just 10 minutes preparation.

And all the time, pitiless judges decided if you won or lost.

In just those two years I competed at roughly 25 tournaments on the regional, national and international level. In between, we'd practice at least 2-3 times a week. I figure I must have done at least 125 competition rounds and another 120 practice rounds or about 400 speeches in total.

I did other debating before and after these two years but never so intensely as this period.

If nothing else, this experience has given me a finely tuned internal BS detector. I just can't help it: I hear a politician or talk radio caller natter on about their favourite topic and my mind starts to tick over finding holes, misstatements, empty rhetoric, junk arguments, made-up history, fallacious attacks etc.

The scary part is how pervasive all these false arguments are and how quickly they are generally accepted. It's alarming to me the ease with which these positions trip off the political (and non-political) and journalistic tongues. These are generally people who really should know better.

I try to do my small part to clarify the public debate to a place where less bullshit reigns. Sometimes I will go on talk radio or whathaveyou and refute some particularly egregious lump of indigestible nonsense.

I've heard debating dismissed as a dry academic elitist activity that has little relation to the real world. They are wrong. The ability to think independently and to clearly articulate solid ideas in a persuasive way is never irrelevant. It's a skill that is useful to the person and the society in which they live.

This province has a proud history of producing great orators and debaters. More than any other place in Canada, we have produced public figures who could reason and speak and persuade. Some used those skills for the greater good of the province, some others used them to further their own ends and more than a few just liked to hear themselves talk.

But those skills should never be left solely in the hands of those who dominate the public stage. Those skills need to be in the minds of their audiences too. It's valuable and necessary to the public environment; it is the very essence of openness, transparency, accountability, fairness and balance.

We need the populace armed with these skills so they can defend themselves against their similarly armed leaders.

I try to do my small part in making this happen. One of my ongoing projects and activities is teaching debating to the next generation coming up through the school system. Lately I've been spending a lot of time with junior high students (some places start a whole lot younger than that, even at primary school), training them for local competitions and then taking them to national events. They do well and they are much stronger in thinking and speaking than you might expect.

What do I teach them? I train them to listen, think and evaluate what they hear. I teach them to never accept what they hear at face value. I teach them to read and digest information so they will understand the world around them. I teach them to reason through a position for themselves using the best tool they will ever have - their power of independent thought.

It's an uphill fight and the hill has never been steeper than it is today. But I always have hope and I figure I'm in this for the long game.

So when I see an editorial from the Telegram that closes with lines like these, I know that there are others who hold dear the same goals as I.
Unless you've already made up your mind on a political issue - whether it's the idea that the federal government destroyed the fishery or the belief that Confederation has been bad for this province, or even that oil companies are corporate monsters robbing a provincial birthright - you owe it to yourself to ensure that you have the most information possible.

We've lost a lot in this province when we've made decisions without complete information.


We've lost even more when we've let political masters tell us what we're supposed to believe.


Ignorance and prejudice are best fought with knowledge - and if there is anything we can give our children, let's remind them of the value of thinking and questioning and learning.

Thursday, May 24, 2007

Seriously? Or irony?

The other day, Bond Papers brought to my attention the editor's column of the Telegram. In it, Russell Wangersky concludes with:
That would give us a media that specializes in cheerleading, printing speeches and delivering political adoration — and I don’t think it is disdain to suggest that that sort of media will serve our politicians very well, but our population not at all.
In part, that conclusion would be based on some observations of the latest shenanigans of The Independent and its Managing Editor, Ryan Cleary. For a sample of those observations, you can check mine here and those by Meeker on Media here.

So when I was tossing the trash this morning, my eye caught this from P3 of the Indy (click to enlarge).

It was the last line that grabbed me - "Maybe they agree with Danny ...".

I really can't tell if this was meant to be irony (because the gentleman quoted expressed a sad sentiment that I've heard frequently from all walks of the business community) or if the editor intended it seriously.

Then again, that question could be asked for most of the paper these days.

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Buddhist politics

At some point I'll write a post on public policy and classical ethical thought systems but, for the moment, this will have to suffice.

Monday, May 21, 2007

Government sponsored Screech-ins

This letter to the Editor of the Telegram (published May 26/07) is in response to a column from Mr. Bill Rowe.


----------------------------------

In his recently weekly column (“Is this how we see ourselves?”), Bill Rowe reprints parts of the Newfie Screech-in ceremony and crossly inquires if that is how we see ourselves. His question was “Where the hell do they get this stuff? This cliche-ridden, shallow, boozy, stereotypical tripe?”

In 1989, as a new staffer in the newly elected Office of the Premier of Clyde Wells, I poked around the office registry and discovered a huge stack of official Newfie Screech-in certificates.

I was told by the office registrar that the practice was to have them signed by the Premier and send them out upon request to anyone who asked. That policy had been in place for as long as she knew (no small amount of time).

Digging a little further, it turned out that the “age-old custom” of Screeching-in was originally developed in the 1960's as a marketing ploy by the Newfoundland and Labrador Liquor Corporation. The goal was to sell more Screech.

However embarrassing or demeaning it might seem now, this “ceremony” was the way we saw ourselves at one point in time. It was a provincial government-sponsored and provincial government-promoted point of view.

Maybe the lesson is that politicians and government agencies are not the best source of information about how we should feel about ourselves. Perhaps we would be better off deciding that independent of the politicians. At least that way our self-image won't be subject to the whims and vagaries of the people in office.

By the way, we shredded the remaining certificates and never sent out another.

Rally for Danny and local media

More than a few local commentators have remarked on the issue of Ryan Cleary, managing editor of the Independent, speaking to the Rally for Trust and Confidence (or Truth and Justice . . . or Stand Up For Newfoundland & Labrador. . . or Our Rightful Role in the Federal Budgetary Process . . . take your choice).

And well they should. His participation wasn't a spur of the moment, caught up in the emotion of the day, sort of thing. It was a premeditated, deliberate choice on his part to speak to the crowd and to be seen doing so.

He even printed his remarks in the Independent before he delivered them.

The media pile-on started almost immediately when CBC's noon show host Jim Furlong asked Cleary the tough question on the issue of compromising journalistic integrity. And when the tough questions start, the evasions begin: his response to the question of integrity was to evade the issue and instead drag other journalists (Cochrane and Wescott) into the fray with him.

Meeker on Media covered the issue and helpfully included the text of the Furlong/Cleary conversation. Then Bob Wakeham weighed in in his column in the Sunday Telegram and poxed all the Wescott, Cochrane and Cleary houses.

Now Mr. Cleary takes the time in this week's Independent to again wrap himself in the NL flag by claiming it's not about the Williams agenda, it's all about standing up for NL.

And that sounds reasonable and sensible on the face of it. Who could be opposed to that?

But the issue that eludes Mr. Cleary is that it's OK to have a NL agenda. Many media have agenda of all kinds, as he points out. That's not really the issue. The essential fact he misses is that there are many NL agendas of all kinds. Some are subsets of others, some are in agreement with others. And some are in conflict with others.

For example, the Confederation battles were all about distinct NL agendas for the future of this land. There were three different formal NL agendas in play during those debates: Confederation, Responsible Government and Economic Union. These agenda were not the same and they were in conflict with each other.

But all three had as their core idea that NL status quo had to be improved, and could be improved, albeit in wildly different directions.

Even today, there are many different NL agendas in play. Premier Williams' is just one and he has been largely successful in pushing all other points of view off the stage. Largely, but not entirely. There is no doubt in my mind that the public environment has become far more intolerant of political alternatives than we have seen for a long time. That, though, will change over time.

But regardless of how Premier Williams demonises those who try to put forward a point of view differing from his own as traitors and shameful and incompetent and treacherous and sell-outs, that does not change the fact that there have been, there are now and there will continue to be legitimate public policy and political alternatives for the future of this province which differ from his.

So what does that have to do with Mr. Cleary's decision to play a prominent role at the rally and how does that differ from Cochrane's and Wescott's actions?

Mr. Cleary has chosen the NL agenda of Premier Wiliams and backs it to the hilt.

And he goes further - his publication disparages or ignores other perfectly legitimate NL agendas which do not have at its core political nationalism, economic autarky and bitter historical grievance.

It's not enough to be proud of the province, says Mr. Cleary, you must be proud in exactly the same way as Premier Williams; his pride is the only legitimate form of pride.

By contrast, Cochrane and Wescott have tried to point out the costs of blindly following that path.

The fact that Mr. Cleary cannot make the distinction between a particular form of provincial pride and the general issue of provincial pride is what transforms him into a partisan.

Cochrane and Wescott fulfilled their journalistic responsibilities; the same cannot be said for Cleary.

Friday, May 18, 2007

"My Liberal credentials are very limited"

The political news of the day is the announcement from Mt. Pearl Mayor Steve Kent that he is running for the Progressive Conservative nomination in the great provincial district of Waterford-Kenmount.

Of course that's not really news. Bond Papers outed him here back on January 23, 2007. No doubt he's been giving the matter so much thought over so much time that it really makes you wonder how much of his municipal activities over the last 6 months or so (including picking a fight with St. John's which Kent himself described as a "considerable stretch") have been done with this announcement in mind.

Reporters gave him a bit of a hard time during his newser to the extent that he had to plead that no, he wasn't being opportunistic. Well, since he's raised the opportunism issue . . .

Mr. Kent says that he feels so strongly about the Progressive Conservative Party of Premier Williams that that's why he became a member and why he's running for the nomination today. And of course it is those things that make him a Progressive Conservative.

And I guess that's his most recent product of his ongoing political development. He has now flirted with, or otherwise participated in the activities of, almost every political party there is to join with the notable exception of the NDP (he's still young).

In 2000, during the federal bye-election in St. John's West, he toyed with the Conservative Alliance/Reform crowd.

The Telegram published stories written by Ryan Cleary (March 25, 2000, Title: Kent shows his colours: Deputy mayor chooses Liberals after flirting with Alliance), quoting emails to CA organisers where Kent stated things like:
"I concluded that it may be in the interest of people of Mount Pearl, and ultimately St. John's West, that I consider offering myself for election. I think that with the right candidate, the Alliance will have a legitimate shot at winning the seat in the upcoming byelection."

"I think, though, that the Alliance provides a meaningful alternative to the status quo that will gain considerable credibility and respect in the months ahead.''

"A new face. A new vision. A new century ... that was my slogan in '97. When I think about the reasons I entered politics, it seems very consistent with where the new Alliance is heading.''
So at the time he sounded pretty positive about the party that has since become the Conservative Party of Canada under Prime Minister Steven Harper.

But it wasn't enough just to be positive about the party he seemed to have chosen, he even had time for a few shots at his (presumed) Liberal political rivals. A piece by John Gushue (The Telegram, March 26, 2000, Title: Youthful indiscretions) noted that:
I also found it curious that Kent took a nasty little crack at his competition in his e-mail to the CA.

"I think we've had enough of the recycled old boys that have been elected and re-elected for years in Newfoundland,'' wrote Kent, who is said to be a favourite of an oft-elected and arguably recycled politician named Brian Tobin.

Former provincial ministers aren't necessarily the best people to represent us in the House of Commons,'' he claimed. Until his candidacy was announced, Kent's competition had been Tom Murphy and Rex Gibbons, both former provincial ministers. (So, too, was Charlie Power, the MP whose resignation sparked all of this.)

Anyway, when it comes to slinging the mud and engaging in the art of war, the little grasshopper has learned much already. Maybe Kent will win the Liberal nomination; maybe he'll even go on to be a decent representative for St. John's West.

But if he wants to campaign on his credibility, he can't.
But why should thoughts like that commit you to running for the CA/Alliance when the siren call of the Natural Governing Party - the Liberal Party of Canada - beckons to you? And sure enough, Mr. Kent succumbed and ran instead for the Liberal nomination in St. John's West.

As Cleary wrote:
Kent, 21, said he was proud to be a card-carrying member of the federal and provincial Liberal parties since 1996. He expressed admiration for Prime Minister Jean Chretien and Premier Brian Tobin.
He lost that nomination fight but no matter. He had finally settled on a party and that party was Liberal, federal and provincial.

And this is the party he stuck by. He was so convinced that this was the party for him that he ran for, and won, a delegate spot at the recent Liberal leadership convention in Montreal that was held November 29 to December 1, 2006. This was after renewing his party membership sometime during the summer of 2006.

And I hear he worked that convention like a pro.

Little wonder reporters looked askance at him when he said "My Liberals credentials are very limited." After all, it was only 2 months from the time of the federal Liberal leadership convention in November to the time his latest political dalliance, this time with the provincial PC's, was outed on January 23.

"Without being too philosophical, I believe that time and circumstances change a great deal in this world," he said today.

Indeed.

I know a lot of people who are supporters of one political party or another and they will consider their party credentials to be fairly firm.

I know a few people who have run for, and won, positions at a national party convention. Those people consider their party credentials aboveboard and hardcore.

And then there are those very few who feel so strongly about their party identification, who consider the ideals of their political party to be so important to the country and province, that they will stick their neck out and actually run for a nomination.

Those people consider their party credentials to be above reproach.

If Mr. Kent considers his Liberal credentials very limited, what would it take for him to openly state, without equivocation, his party loyalties?

Perhaps a firm shot at a safe seat?

I think I'll just leave this matter in the hands of Mr. Gushue who wrote in the Telegram that:
Somehow, one gets the impression that Kent sees the Liberals and the CA/Reform crowd as just different brands on a shelf, labels with which he can continue to develop -- in his mind -- a more important product: Steve Kent.

Time for Wells to resign from CNLOPB (1)

I number this blog post (1) because I'm sure I will be producing more of these over time simply because, as sure as the sun rises in the east, Mayor Wells does not know how to keep a civil tongue in his head.

Remember, this is the man who recently embarrassed himself, his city and his position on the CNLOPB Board by arguing at a recent oil conference that the province needed to separate from Canada in order to get more clout over the offshore.

The habit he has of bitterly shooting off his mouth at whatever target he feels has done him wrong will be sure to put him in a bad spot. He just can't help it.

Sure enough, it has already started and you can read it here on CBC.

In the March edition of OilWeek magazine, Wells said he believed the board had not properly handled a proposal for the Hibernia South development, and even suggested the board was "incompetent."

On April 27, Ruelokke sent a letter to the federal and provincial natural resource ministers, alleging Wells violated conflict of interest guidelines. "Such comments speak to the integrity of the board and are clearly inconsistent with the principle that members shall act in good interests of the board in a manner that conserves and enhances public confidence and trust," Ruelokke wrote.

In classic Wells fashion, Wells responded with, "He can get stuffed on that. He's not going to be telling me how I'm going to respond to any issues that come before this board. I'm not going to stand by and allow some bureaucratic hack to tell me what I can and cannot say on matters of public interest."

If Mayor Wells feels strongly about the incompetence of the Board and the Chair, Max Ruelokke, then he should do the honourable thing and resign. But he won't.

Instead he will continue to snipe for the sidelines, sit in the corner of the room in board meetings and sulk and whine while the other members try to do their job and generally do all he can to undermine the Board and Chairman Ruelokke in public and in private.

Wells will do all he can to force the Board to take the actions necessary to remove him. Then Wells will do what he always do when he's crossed in public - he will sue. Will he win his suit? I doubt it. Wells' modus operandi is now well-known from as far back as his days on the Public Utilities Board when he was removed from that regulatory agency (through improper procedures, the courts ruled).

This time the CNLOPB will ensure that all i's will be dotted and all t's crossed at every step of the slow and inexorable removal process to forestall any liability issues. But if he keeps up this nonsense then remove him they will.

So what will Wells' spiteful scorched-earth policy accomplish? In the short-term there will be much noise and smoke and flaming from Wells and his provincial government allies. No doubt there will be more talk of Ottawa stabbing the people of the province in the back. The talk radio lines will be swarmed with his slavish and short-sighted supporters.

But in the long view, there will be few ill effects and more than a few positive ones. Wells will be removed from a Board he never had any credentials or background to join, Ruelokke will stay as chair in a much more peaceable environment and the offshore oil and gas regulatory universe will unfold as it should.

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

No quotas, no chance, no way

It's not the first time this provincial government has tried to get through the back door what they failed to get at the front door. But this time the lives and livelihoods of a huge number of vulnerable plantworkers and harvesters from all across the province are being held hostage.

Let's review: FPI has made arrangements to sell chunks of itself to a host of interests both inside and outside the province. These sales are governed by the FPI Act such that the government of NL must provide approval for these asset transfers.

So what is Minister Rideout's position? Does he want to expedite the sale of these interests in order to get people back to work as soon as possible?

No. Instead this government has decided to strike with sudden power grab. The Government of Canada, insists Minister Rideout, must turn over control of groundfish quotas that FPI now holds to the Newfoundland and Labrador government. He says the provincial government is making its unusual request so that Newfoundland and Labrador communities remain the primary beneficiaries of quotas that FPI currently holds.

This looks like nothing more than an expedient attempt to politically blackmail a federal minister on the ropes.

Remember that there is no doubt anywhere that, legally and constitutionally, the federal government is the sole authority over harvesting in the oceans. So what Rideout is asking for is for a unilateral transfer of federal authority and constitutional jurisdiction.

Oddly, federal Minister Hearn is not quite so enthused to do that when exactly the the same provincial benefits can be achieved through simply setting conditions on where groundfish can be landed. It's done all the time. But now, today, in this case, that's not good enough for Rideout and company and so war with the feds on yet another front must be waged.

Premier Danny Williams said he was not surprised by the federal Conservatives' stand, particularly in the midst of an ongoing battle over equalization.

He is wrong; equalization has absolutely nothing to do with the substance of this issue and he has to know that. The fact is that there is no way under any circumstances that the feds are about to formally transfer any authority to the province when a simple administrative process would do the job.

FFAW president Earle McCurdy said his members are worried about a political struggle overshadowing their need to get back to work.

They should be worried.

For the same reasons this fishing restructuring process has stalled under new demands by Premier Williams in the 11th hour, thousands of oil sector jobs across the province have already evaporated. The experienced and trained oil workers are mobile and their skills are in high demand in other jurisdictions - they are out of sight and out of mind.

But these idle plantworkers and harvesters are more likely to stay where they are and become a festering problem.

This government's ability to handle issues of major provincial economic public policy is hampered by it's hamfisted inability to play with others. Let's hope government is more sensible over fish than oil.

Who will we blame then?

Just a few days before the Rally for Danny, it's worth considering the hothouse environment we have created here. When Greg Locke talked about the weight lifted off his shoulders when he got off the ferry in Sydney, and at the risk of putting words in his mouth, I think he meant the relief from the increasing intensity of local politics.

It's an environment which has inspired the True Believers of the point of view that we have been screwed, we are being screwed and we will always be screwed. This self-righteousness provides the license to attack anyone in any way no matter how crude or irrelevant.

Vicious umbrage is taken at legitimate alternative points of view. That is when anybody dares to risk the ridicule and attack that might come with raising an alternate legitimate point of view.

The radical neo-nationalist local ideologies are becoming mainstream. The rhetoric, even from those in responsible positions who have a responsibility to know and do better, has been ratcheted up to intense levels.

Those who dissent are disruptors, traitors, sellouts.

Every issue, every point of difference and every negotiation has become the opportunity for civil war. The other side must be humiliated to achieve our tribal goals. All this furious local activity takes the time, space and resources that could be better put to the good of the people of the province.

In the meantime the world goes on, business goes on and life goes on. In the end we don't and won't feel better for all the shouting. And we won't be better off for it. We will be spent, exhausted and hung-over wondering what happened.

Then it will be time to pick up the pieces and repair the damage we have done to ourselves.

By that time our children will have taken the plane to Alberta leaving behind bewildered parents who will never know their grandchildren except as Christmas visitors on alternate years.

Who will we blame then?


----------------------

Williams' plan a tough sell for Big Oil - Premier's attempt at equity stake may leave province out in the cold

by Claudia Cattaneo, Financial Post, Tuesday, May 08, 2007

Danny Williams, premier of Newfoundland and Labrador, sent shivers through the country when his government served notice in a Throne Speech two weeks ago of its intentions to be "masters of our own house."

Mr. Williams was reinforcing this message: His province will no longer be bullied -- in his view -- by outside interests, whether by the federal government, which cut its transfer payments, or the likes of oil companies, fishing for unfair deals on its offshore deposits.

It is a popular message in a province where the perceived inequities of the past continue to loom large.

Yet what is becoming increasingly obvious is that control of Newfoundland's future is slipping into the hands of Alberta, largely because of Mr. Williams' unrealistic expectations and the market's dispassionate behaviour.

Canada's two top oil-producing economies are developing such a strong symmetry they are becoming either/or situations in a skills-challenged reality, to the point it may take a big downturn in Alberta for Newfoundland to get a shot at benefiting from its offshore riches in the future. Three reasons: - Oil is badly needed, but labour and brains to produce it are now needed even more. Newfoundland's people and oil services companies are moving to Alberta in large numbers. The exodus is so large that Newfoundland's business community fears the province no longer has the workforce to build a new project, even if one were announced tomorrow. It also worries it cannot compete with Alberta wages, making any attempt to lure its people back futile.

The high-unemployment province has been a supplier of talent to the rest of Canada for generations. However, that outflow picked up a year ago, when the premier and oil companies failed to nail terms on development of the fourth major offshore development, $6-billion Hebron Ben Nevis.

Other potential projects, also worth billions, from exploration programs to an extension of the Hibernia South reservoir, are on hold as industry waits --and worries --about Mr. Williams' long-awaited energy plan.

The result is that for the first time in 15 years, Newfoundland does not have an offshore energy project in the pipeline.

Alberta's policies encourage energy development, while Newfoundland's are guaranteed to push it away.

Mr. Williams is expected to release an energy policy before the next provincial election in October, making it mandatory for the government to hold equity stakes in all future oil and gas projects.

In an interview with the Financial Post last week, the premier said the province would demand stakes of more than 4.9%, the amount it negotiated for the Hebron. The province is also likely to demand a high level of local investment by oil companies and super-royalties that would increase with higher commodity prices.

The terms would result in a high degree of government involvement that is likely to be unacceptable to oil companies. In addition, the fiscal terms would make Newfoundland uncompetitive with Alberta, where the government has not owned a piece of the oil industry since it sold Alberta Energy Co. (the predecessor of EnCana Corp.) 20 years ago; its royalty rates, while under review, do not escalate with higher commodity prices; and there is no requirement to invest locally, other than a preference by the government to keep as much heavy oil upgrading in the province as possible.

Most companies with interests in Newfoundland's offshore now have ambitious oilsands plans. In fact, those plans have escalated since Hebron talks failed, making a return to the East Coast a hard task: ExxonMobil Corp. is a partner in the Kearl Lake project and has taken a larger role in the management of the Syncrude mining consortium; Petro-Canada is priming its Fort Hills project for takeoff in the summer; Chevron Corp. is a partner in the Athabasca Oil Sands Project, which is expanding aggressively; ConocoPhillips has its hands full with a major oilsands partnership with EnCana and interests in two other oilsands projects; Husky Energy Inc. just bought a major refinery in the United States as part of its own oilsands strategy.

Even Norsk Hydro, the Norwegian oil company that has been taken over by Statoil ASA, made a big leap in the oilsands two weeks ago when it purchased North American Oil Sands Corp. and now plans to become one of its largest operators.

The bottom line: While Mr. Williams now tries to revive Hebron discussions and says he is optimistic its partners will accept a deal, warning terms will tougher with his new energy plan, his province is sitting out the biggest boom in the commodity's history, while Alberta is milking it for all it's worth.

He will need to beat Alberta -- not live in the past -- to get in on the next round.

Monday, May 07, 2007

Email to Lawrence Martin

I don't normally send out emails to columnists but today's column by Lawrence Martin in the Globe and Mail provoked me into a response. . .

Sir:

You wrote in your column published today that:
"The Prime Minister is a model for the entire country. If he resorts to mudslinging instead of showing a measure of graciousness, others will be inclined follow suit. If he starts throwing around baseless allegations, others - right down to our high-school debating clubs - will be inclined to do the same."
Coming from the province of Newfoundland and Labrador, I can tell you that civility in public life has certainly taken a beating around here.

But as a long-time debate coach, former debater and debate organizer on the local and national levels, I can assure you that this kind of behavior will not be tolerated in the next generation of high school debaters without a fight. They might be inclined, but they won't be encouraged.

If the Prime Minister, and other politicians, behave themselves and are an appropriate model for debate comportment, then coaches will hold them up as a positive example to be emulated and they will be rewarded.

If they sling mud or otherwise throw around baseless allegations, they will be help up as a negative model to be avoided; students will be penalized for traveling down that path.

If more politicians were penalized by more Canadians for slurs and slagging, things would improve.

Simon Lono
President of the Newfoundland and Labrador Speech and Debate Union
Past-President of Canadian Student Debating Federation.

Sunday, May 06, 2007

The Independent does us proud

This week the Independent has given over 1/4 of the front page and their entire first section centerspread to serious impartial investigative journalism.

Pick it up to read the entire speech, word-for-word, recently delivered by Premier Williams at the Economic Club of Toronto.

It's not like you couldn't already find it here on the official government web site. And it's not like they made even a veiled attempt to provide any kind of analysis or insight into it like other media did here and here or even like blogs did like here or here.

Nope. Instead they just handed over some prime areas of the only thing newspapers have to offer - print real estate - over to this government free of charge without any comment or analysis. Or even any semblance of justification.

Is this journalistic laziness or an explicit effort to kiss the Premier's feet or just an example where ideological principles have overridden journalistic integrity?

Regardless of which it is, it wouldn't be the first time for any of them and it likely won't be the last.